1–4
Player Influence
Anthony Kay
Anthony Kay allowed two unearned runs on two hits and two walks with three strikeouts across four innings pitched on 66 pitches.
- pitches
- 66
- innings appeared
- 1–4
MLB
September 16, 2026 · Progressive Field
Chicago White Sox at Cleveland Guardians Game Analysis — September 16, 2026
| Team | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | R | H | E |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CHW | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 3 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 3 | 8 | 1 |
| CLE | 0 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 4 | 0 | 0 | — | 6 | 5 | 0 |
Follow the scoring sequence from the first run to the final margin.
CHWScoreCLE
- 30–2Supports the analysis
Adell singled to left, Halpin scored and Kwan scored.
- 5Supports the analysis
Pham homered to left center (412 feet), Meidroth scored and Grichuk scored.
3–2 - 63–5Supports the analysis
Halpin homered to right center (393 feet), Fry scored and Hedges scored.
- 3–6Supports the analysis
Ramírez doubled to left, Rocchio scored, Kwan to third.
Read the plays and performances in chronological order, or filter the view by team.
- 1–6
Starting Pitching
Parker Messick
Cleveland starting pitcher Parker Messick limited Chicago to three runs across six innings pitched, recording eight strikeouts with zero walks allowed while earning the victory.
- pitches
- 86
- innings appeared
- 1–6
- 1–6
Player Influence
Parker Messick
Parker Messick threw 86 pitches (62 strikes) across six innings, allowing seven hits and three earned runs while striking out eight without a walk.
- pitches
- 86
- innings appeared
- 1–6
- 3–9 · linked
3–9
Analysis
The Cleveland Guardians defeated the Chicago White Sox 6-3, scoring all six runs across two multi-run rallies in the third and sixth innings.
- ▼ 3
Scoring Sequence
Jo Adell · Anthony Kay · Petey Halpin · Steven Kwan · Chase Meidroth
Cleveland took an initial 2-0 lead in the bottom of the third inning when Jo Adell delivered a two-out, two-run single following a Chicago fielding error.
Anthony Kay pitch selection by count
Observed pitch-type mix across 4 count groups (65 valid pitches). - ▼ 3
Scoring Sequence
Jo Adell · Anthony Kay
Jo Adell hit a two-out single to left field off Anthony Kay on a 94.6 mph cutter in the third inning, scoring Halpin and Kwan.
- ▼ 3
Base Out State
Chase Meidroth · Steven Kwan · Petey Halpin
In the third inning, a fielding error by Chase Meidroth on Steven Kwan's grounder allowed Petey Halpin to advance to third base with one out.
- ▲ 5
Scoring Sequence
Tommy Pham · Parker Messick
Tommy Pham hit an 80.7 mph curveball for a 412-foot three-run home run to left-center field with two outs in the fifth inning.
- 5–6
Player Influence
Hagen Smith
Hagen Smith was charged with the loss after allowing two earned runs, one hit, and two walks over 1.2 innings of relief.
- pitches
- 30
- innings appeared
- 5–6
- ▼ 6
Scoring Sequence
Petey Halpin · Sean Newcomb
Petey Halpin hit a 393-foot three-run home run to right-center field on a 3-1 sinker (94.3 mph) from Sean Newcomb with two outs in the sixth inning.
- ▼ 6
Scoring Sequence
Jose Ramirez · Sean Newcomb · Brayan Rocchio
Jose Ramirez drove in Brayan Rocchio with an RBI double to left field on a 96.5 mph fastball from Sean Newcomb in the sixth inning.
- 7–8
Bullpen Usage
Noah Schultz
Noah Schultz tossed two perfect innings of relief for Chicago across the seventh and eighth innings, retiring all six batters faced on 18 pitches.
- pitches
- 18
- innings appeared
- 7–8
- 7–9
Bullpen Usage
Hunter Gaddis · Erik Sabrowski · Cade Smith
Cleveland relievers Hunter Gaddis, Erik Sabrowski, and Cade Smith combined for three scoreless innings, allowing one hit and two walks with two strikeouts.
- 8–9
Bullpen Leverage
Cade Smith · Sam Antonacci
Cade Smith secured a four-out save by retiring all four batters faced, stranding two inherited eighth-inning runners and striking out two in the ninth inning.
- pitches
- 15
- innings appeared
- 8–9
Cleveland Guardians pitcher deployment
Observed pitching-staff sequence by inning (4 pitchers, 3 subsequent).
See what the reviewed evidence supports—and where its limits are.
Cleveland actually used the extra out
MediumAdell drove in two unearned runs with a two-out single after an infield fielding error extended the third inning.
Evidence
Bottom 3
- Petey Halpin vs Anthony Kay
- Steven Kwan vs Anthony Kay
- Jo Adell vs Anthony Kay
- Pitch 4 : Ball In Play
- Kwan grounded into fielder's choice to second, Halpin to second, Halpin safe at third on fielding error by second baseman Meidroth.
- Pitch 1 : Ball In Play
Bottom 3
- Adell singled to left, Halpin scored and Kwan scored.
- Base/out transitions · Bottom 3
- Anthony Kay · 4 IP · 2 H · 0 ER · 3 K · 2 BB · 66 pitches
Not implied
- Does not imply systemic defensive vulnerability beyond the recorded error.
- Does not establish hitter clutch rating.
Limitations
- Defensive alignment positioning is not rendered in the evidence.
Messick kept the damage to one swing
MediumMessick struck out eight batters without walking any over six innings, allowing three runs on Pham's fifth-inning home run.
Evidence
- Parker Messick · 6 IP · 7 H · 3 ER · 8 K · 0 BB · 86 pitches · W
- Parker Messick · 86 pitches · innings 1–6
Top 5
- Tommy Pham vs Parker Messick
- Pham homered to left center (412 feet), Meidroth scored and Grichuk scored.
- Parker Messick · Changeup · 28% usage
- Parker Messick · 4-Seam Fastball · 40% usage
Not implied
- Does not establish repertoire dominance or pitch-tunneling execution.
- Does not imply season-long starter durability or talent tier.
Limitations
- Does not include unrendered pitch command grades or advance scouting preparation.
The save started before the ninth
MediumCade Smith ended Chicago's eighth-inning threat by stranding two runners and completed a scoreless save across 1.1 innings.
Evidence
- Cade Smith · 1.1 IP · 0 H · 0 ER · 2 K · 0 BB · 15 pitches
- Cade Smith · bullpen · 15 pitches · innings 8–9
- Cade Smith · 15 pitches · innings 8–9
Top 8
- Sam Antonacci vs Cade Smith
Top 9
- Tristan Peters vs Cade Smith
- Chase Meidroth vs Cade Smith
- Randal Grichuk vs Cade Smith
- Smith relieved Sabrowski
- Antonacci flied out to center.
Not implied
- Does not prove long-term bullpen hierarchy roles beyond this appearance.
- Does not imply psychological clutch performance beyond the recorded outs.
Limitations
- Leverage index and bullpen usage philosophy are not explicitly rendered in the grounding view.