MLB

September 23, 2026 · Yankee Stadium

Tampa Bay Rays at New York Yankees Game Analysis — September 23, 2026

Team123456789RHE
TB000110000261
NYY11510001—9121

Scoring path

Follow the scoring sequence from the first run to the final margin.

TBScoreNYY
  1. 1
    0–1

    Rice homered to right (379 feet).

  2. 2
    0–2
    Supports the analysis

    McMahon singled to center, Jones scored.

  3. 3
    0–3

    Lombard Jr. homered to right center (384 feet).

  4. 0–7
    Supports the analysis

    McMahon homered to right (332 feet), García Jr. scored, Chisholm Jr. scored and Caballero scored.

  5. 4

    DeLuca doubled to right, Hicks scored.

    1–7
  6. 1–8

    Rice homered to right center (383 feet).

  7. 5
    Supports the analysis

    Mullins homered to right (375 feet).

    2–8
  8. 8
    2–9
    Supports the analysis

    Ramos hit sacrifice fly to right, Sánchez scored, Rice to third.

Key observations by inning

Read the plays and performances in chronological order, or filter the view by team.

  1. 1–4

    Starting Pitching Performance

    Mason Englert

    Tampa Bay starting pitcher Mason Englert surrendered eight earned runs on nine hits and one walk over 3.2 innings, allowing four home runs before being removed in the fourth inning.

    pitches
    86
    innings appeared
    1–4
  2. 1–6 · linked

    Starting Pitching Two-strike Execution

    Gerrit Cole

    Gerrit Cole generated eight strikeouts over 5.2 innings by varying two-strike putaways across three pitches, finishing three strikeouts on four-seam fastballs, three on sliders, and two on knuckle curves.

    Gerrit Cole pitch selection by count

    Observed pitch-type mix across 5 count groups (105 valid pitches).

    Observed pitch-type mix across 5 count groups (105 valid pitches).

    Observed pitch-type mix across 5 count groups (105 valid pitches).
  3. 1–8 · linked

    Individual Batting Performance

    Ben Rice · Mason Englert

    Ben Rice hit two solo home runs off Mason Englert and finished with three hits, two runs scored, two RBIs, and a walk in five plate appearances.

  4. 2–3 · linked

    Player Influence

    Ryan McMahon

    Ryan McMahon recorded five RBIs on two hits, driving in a run with a second-inning single and adding four on a third-inning grand slam.

  5. 3–9 · linked

    Player Influence

    Jorge Mateo · Gerrit Cole · David Bednar

    Jorge Mateo struck out in three of his four plate appearances, striking out twice against Gerrit Cole and once against David Bednar.

  6. ▼ 3

    Player Influence

    George Lombard Jr.

    George Lombard Jr. hit a solo home run to right-center field in the third inning, his only hit in five plate appearances.

  7. 4–8 · linked

    Individual Offensive Performance

    Jonny DeLuca

    Jonny DeLuca collected three of Tampa Bay's six total hits, driving in a run with a fourth-inning double and successfully stealing second and third base in the eighth inning.

    New York Yankees pitcher deployment

    Observed pitching-staff sequence by inning (6 pitchers, 5 subsequent).

    Observed pitching-staff sequence by inning (6 pitchers, 5 subsequent).

    Observed pitching-staff sequence by inning (6 pitchers, 5 subsequent).
  8. ▲ 5

    Player Influence

    Cedric Mullins · Gerrit Cole

    Cedric Mullins hit a solo home run on a 3-2 fastball from Gerrit Cole in the fifth inning for Tampa Bay's second run.

  9. ▲ 6

    Substitution Window

    Nick Fortes · Junior Caminero

    Nick Fortes entered as a pinch-hitter for Junior Caminero in the sixth inning and remained in the game at catcher.

  10. ▲6–▼6

    Bullpen Usage

    Brody Hopkins

    Brody Hopkins pitched a scoreless sixth inning with two strikeouts and one walk, throwing 16 pitches.

  11. ▲7–▼7

    Bullpen Usage

    Tim Hill · John Schreiber

    Tim Hill entered with one out and runners on first and second in the seventh inning, stranding both inherited runners on two groundouts.

  12. ▼ 8

    Scoring Sequence

    Heliot Ramos · Ali Sanchez

    Heliot Ramos extended New York's lead to 9-2 in the eighth inning with a sacrifice fly to right field, scoring Ali Sanchez.

  13. ▲9–▼9

    Bullpen Usage

    David Bednar

    David Bednar closed the ninth inning on 16 pitches, retiring Ryan Vilade, Cedric Mullins, and Jorge Mateo in order.

What this game can—and can’t tell us

TBNYYShared

See what the reviewed evidence supports—and where its limits are.

  • Englert's outing made this a short game early

    High

    Englert allowed eight runs and four home runs across 3.2 innings before being relieved.

    Evidence

    • Mason Englert · 3.2 IP · 9 H · 8 ER · 6 K · 1 BB · 86 pitches · L
    • Mason Englert · 86 pitches · innings 1–4
    • Legumina relieved Englert

    Bottom 1

    • Rice homered to right (379 feet).

    Bottom 3

    • Lombard Jr. homered to right center (384 feet).
    • McMahon homered to right (332 feet), García Jr. scored, Chisholm Jr. scored and Caballero scored.

    Bottom 4

    • Rice homered to right center (383 feet).

    Not implied

    • Does not imply poor future performance or general repertoire inadequacy beyond this outing.

    Limitations

    • Does not evaluate mechanical execution or advance scouting preparation.
    Mason EnglertTampa Bay Rays
  • Cole kept changing the two-strike question

    Medium

    Cole effectively used fastballs, sliders, and knuckle curves to record eight strikeouts across multiple innings.

    Evidence

    • Gerrit Cole · 5.2 IP · 3 H · 2 ER · 8 K · 3 BB · 105 pitches · W

    Top 1

    • Jonathan Aranda vs Gerrit Cole
    • Slider · 89.4 mph · Swinging Strike

    Top 2

    • Jonny DeLuca vs Gerrit Cole
    • 4-Seam Fastball · 97.5 mph · Called Strike

    Top 3

    • Jorge Mateo vs Gerrit Cole
    • Knuckle Curve · 84 mph · Swinging Strike
    • Knuckle Curve · 80.9 mph · Swinging Strike

    Top 4

    • Richie Palacios vs Gerrit Cole
    • Slider · 91.3 mph · Called Strike

    Top 5

    • Ryan Vilade vs Gerrit Cole
    • 4-Seam Fastball · 95.9 mph · Foul Tip
    • 4-Seam Fastball · 96.3 mph · Foul Tip

    Top 6

    • Nick Fortes vs Gerrit Cole
    • Slider · 89.7 mph · Swinging Strike
    • Gerrit Cole · 4-Seam Fastball · 55% usage
    • Gerrit Cole · Knuckle Curve · 18% usage
    • Gerrit Cole · Slider · 22% usage

    Not implied

    • This does not prove pitch-tunneling deception or catcher framing intent.

    Limitations

    • Pitch sequences reflect observable pitch choices and do not prove pre-game scouting scripts.
  • Rice was the cleanest version of the damage

    High

    Ben Rice produced two home runs off starter Mason Englert and reached base four times in five plate appearances.

    Evidence

    • Ben Rice · 3-for-4 · 2 HR · 1 BB

    Bottom 1

    • Ben Rice vs Mason Englert

    Bottom 6

    • Ben Rice vs Brody Hopkins

    Bottom 8

    • Ben Rice vs Cole Sulser

    Bottom 1

    • Rice homered to right (379 feet).

    Bottom 4

    • Rice homered to right center (383 feet).
    • Mason Englert vs Ben Rice · 11 pitches · Groundout, Home Run

    Not implied

    • This single game does not establish long-term platoon splits or season-level offensive production.

    Limitations

    • Sample is restricted to five plate appearances in this contest.
    Ben RiceNew York YankeesMason Englert
  • DeLuca was almost the entire Rays offense

    High

    DeLuca accounted for half of Tampa Bay's hits and generated offense through extra-base hitting and baserunning.

    Evidence

    • Jonny DeLuca · 3-for-4 · 1 K
    • Final score 2–9

    Top 4

    • Jonny DeLuca vs Gerrit Cole
    • Pitch 7 : Ball In Play

    Top 4

    • DeLuca doubled to right, Hicks scored.

    Top 6

    • Jonny DeLuca vs Brent Headrick
    • Pitch 1 : Ball In Play

    Top 8

    • Jonny DeLuca vs Paul Blackburn
    • Pitch 2 : Ball In Play
    • DeLuca stole second.
    • DeLuca stole third.

    Not implied

    • Does not prove regular season stolen base efficiency or full-season batting profile.

    Limitations

    • Sample is four plate appearances in one game.
    Jonny DeLucaTampa Bay Rays