MLB

October 5, 2026 · Tropicana Field

New York Yankees at Tampa Bay Rays Game Analysis — October 5, 2026

Team123456789RHE
NYY000100010244
TB10004000—580

Scoring path

Follow the scoring sequence from the first run to the final margin.

NYYScoreTB
  1. 1
    0–1
    Supports the analysis

    Caminero grounded into fielder's choice to shortstop, Díaz scored on throwing error by second baseman Chisholm Jr., Aranda out at second, Caminero to second.

  2. 4
    Supports the analysis

    Rice homered to right (372 feet).

    1–1
  3. 5
    1–2
    Supports the analysis

    Hicks grounded out to second, Aranda scored, Caminero to third.

  4. 1–3
    Supports the analysis

    Simpson grounded into fielder's choice to shortstop, Caminero scored.

  5. 1–5
    Supports the analysis

    Palacios singled to center, Simpson scored and DeLuca scored.

  6. 8
    Supports the analysis

    Rice homered to right (358 feet).

    2–5

Key observations by inning

Read the plays and performances in chronological order, or filter the view by team.

  1. 1–5

    Starting Pitching

    Freddy Peralta

    Freddy Peralta held New York to one run across 4.2 innings while throwing 65.2% four-seam fastballs (43 pitches) and 30.3% changeups (20 pitches), generating 11 whiffs across those two pitch types to keep the Yankees mostly off the scoreboard.

    pitches
    66
    innings appeared
    1–5
  2. ▼ 1

    Defensive Run Prevention

    Ryan McMahon · Jazz Chisholm Jr. · Austin Wells · George Lombard Jr.

    New York committed four fielding errors that directly contributed to three unearned runs, with throwing errors in the first and fifth innings allowing Tampa Bay to score and extend innings on only two earned runs charged to Yankees pitching.

  3. ▼ 1

    Scoring Sequence

    Junior Caminero · Yandy Diaz · Jazz Chisholm Jr.

    Tampa Bay opened the scoring in the bottom of the first inning when Junior Caminero reached on a fielder's choice and an error by second baseman Jazz Chisholm Jr. allowed Yandy Diaz to score.

  4. 3–5 · linked

    Player Influence

    Junior Caminero

    Junior Caminero collected two hits in four at-bats, highlighted by a fifth-inning double to center field that placed runners on second and third with no outs.

  5. 4–8 · linked

    Plate Appearances Vs Peralta And Seymour

    Ben Rice

    Ben Rice accounted for all of New York's scoring by hitting two solo home runs—a 372-foot homer in the fourth inning off Freddy Peralta and a 358-foot shot in the eighth inning off Ian Seymour—in the Yankees' 5-2 loss.

  6. ▲ 5

    Two-out High-leverage Relief Appearance

    Cam Booser · Cody Bellinger

    Entering with two outs and two runners on in a 1-1 game in the fifth inning, Cam Booser walked Ben Rice to load the bases but induced an inning-ending flyout from Cody Bellinger, stranding all three runners to keep the score tied.

    Top of the 5th — bases and outs

    5 plate-appearance transitions in the top of inning 5.

    5 plate-appearance transitions in the top of inning 5.

    5 plate-appearance transitions in the top of inning 5.
  7. ▲5–▼5

    Go-ahead Scoring Rally

    Jonathan Aranda · Junior Caminero · Richie Palacios

    In the bottom of the fifth inning, Tampa Bay broke a 1-1 tie by executing a four-run rally initiated by consecutive hits from Jonathan Aranda and Junior Caminero, capitalizing on base-out pressure before Richie Palacios drove in two runs with a two-out single.

    New York Yankees pitcher deployment

    Observed pitching-staff sequence by inning (6 pitchers, 5 subsequent).

    Observed pitching-staff sequence by inning (6 pitchers, 5 subsequent).

    Observed pitching-staff sequence by inning (6 pitchers, 5 subsequent).
  8. 5–8

    Bullpen Usage

    Brent Headrick · John Schreiber · Ryan Weathers · Paul Blackburn · David Bednar

    New York utilized five relief pitchers across the final 3.2 innings—Brent Headrick, John Schreiber, Ryan Weathers, Paul Blackburn, and David Bednar—yielding two hits, one unearned run, and one walk.

  9. 5–9

    Bullpen Usage

    Cam Booser · Ian Seymour · Bryan Baker

    Tampa Bay's relievers Cam Booser, Ian Seymour, and Bryan Baker combined for 4.1 innings of one-run ball, allowing only one hit and one walk while striking out four batters.

  10. ▼ 5

    Base Out State

    Chandler Simpson · Jonny DeLuca · Brent Headrick

    Chandler Simpson and Jonny DeLuca both stole second base in the bottom of the fifth inning against Brent Headrick, setting up both runners to score on Richie Palacios's two-run single.

  11. 6–8

    Middle-to-late Relief

    Ian Seymour

    Ian Seymour pitched three innings of relief for Tampa Bay across the sixth, seventh, and eighth innings, allowing one run on a solo home run to Ben Rice while striking out four batters and walking none on 41 pitches.

    pitches
    41
    innings appeared
    6–8

    Ian Seymour pitch selection by count

    Observed pitch-type mix across 4 count groups (41 valid pitches).

    Observed pitch-type mix across 4 count groups (41 valid pitches).

    Observed pitch-type mix across 4 count groups (41 valid pitches).
  12. ▼ 8

    Substitution Window

    Jorge Mateo · Yandy Diaz

    Jorge Mateo entered as a pinch runner for Yandy Diaz after Diaz's two-out single in the eighth inning and took over as designated hitter in the ninth inning.

  13. ▲9–▼9

    Save Opportunity

    Bryan Baker

    Bryan Baker earned a save by pitching a scoreless ninth inning, retiring Spencer Jones, George Lombard Jr., and Jazz Chisholm Jr. on three consecutive groundouts using nine pitches (six strikes).

    pitches
    9
    innings appeared
    9

What this game can—and can’t tell us

NYYTBShared

See what the reviewed evidence supports—and where its limits are.

  • The game turned before Tampa Bay hit in the fifth

    Medium

    Booser stranded three inherited and created runners in the fifth inning to prevent New York from taking the lead.

    Evidence

    • Booser relieved Peralta
    • Rice walked, McMahon to second, Wells to third.
    • Bellinger flied out to center.

    Top 5

    • Ben Rice vs Cam Booser
    • Cody Bellinger vs Cam Booser
    • Base/out transitions · Top 5
    • Cam Booser · 0.1 IP · 0 H · 0 ER · 0 K · 1 BB · 8 pitches · W

    Not implied

    • This does not prove managerial prescience in summoning Booser.
    • This does not establish permanent high-leverage reliability for the pitcher.

    Limitations

    • Does not imply Booser's pitch selection was intentionally designed to pitch around Rice.
    Cam BooserCody BellingerTampa Bay Rays
  • Then the Rays cashed their own traffic all the way in

    Medium

    Tampa Bay converted early traffic and two-out pressure into four runs in the fifth inning to take control of the game.

    Evidence

    • Score after inning 5: 0–4

    Bottom 5th

    • Hicks grounded out to second, Aranda scored, Caminero to third.
    • Simpson grounded into fielder's choice to shortstop, Caminero scored.
    • Palacios singled to center, Simpson scored and DeLuca scored.

    Bottom 5

    • Jonathan Aranda vs Cam Schlittler
    • Junior Caminero vs Cam Schlittler
    • Liam Hicks vs Cam Schlittler
    • Chandler Simpson vs Cam Schlittler
    • Jonny DeLuca vs Brent Headrick
    • Richie Palacios vs Brent Headrick

    Not implied

    • This does not prove opposing pitchers suffered physical fatigue or collapsed.
    • This does not imply pre-game strategic design led directly to the rally.

    Limitations

    • Does not prove pre-inning tactical adjustments or intentional pitch-selection execution.
    Tampa Bay RaysJonathan ArandaJunior CamineroRichie Palacios
  • New York kept adding cost to its own innings

    Medium

    Defensive errors contributed materially to three of Tampa Bay's five runs by extending innings.

    Evidence

    • Final score 2–5
    • Díaz safe at first on fielding error by third baseman McMahon.

    Bottom 1

    • Caminero grounded into fielder's choice to shortstop, Díaz scored on throwing error by second baseman Chisholm Jr., Aranda out at second, Caminero to second.
    • Hicks reached first base on catcher's interference. Tampa Bay Rays challenged: call on the field was overturned.
    • DeLuca safe at first on throwing error by shortstop Lombard Jr., Simpson safe at third on error.
    • Cam Schlittler · 4.1 IP · 6 H · 2 ER · 2 K · 1 BB · 76 pitches · L
    • Brent Headrick · 0.2 IP · 1 H · 0 ER · 1 K · 0 BB · 18 pitches
    • Ryan McMahon · 0-for-1 · 1 BB
    • Jazz Chisholm Jr. · 0-for-4 · 1 K
    • Austin Wells · 1-for-3 · 2 K
    • George Lombard Jr. · 0-for-4 · 1 K

    Not implied

    • This does not establish a systemic or season-long defensive deficit.
    • This does not imply lack of preparation or focus by the defense.

    Limitations

    • Does not measure individual fielder range or mechanics beyond rendered play outcomes.
    New York YankeesRyan McMahonJazz Chisholm Jr.Austin WellsGeorge Lombard Jr.
  • Seymour made the fifth inning hold up

    High

    Seymour covered three innings of relief with four strikeouts and one run allowed to bridge the game to the ninth inning.

    Evidence

    • Ian Seymour · 3 IP · 1 H · 1 ER · 4 K · 0 BB · 41 pitches
    • Ian Seymour · bullpen · 41 pitches · innings 6–8
    • Ian Seymour · 41 pitches · innings 6–8

    Top 8

    • Rice homered to right (358 feet).

    Top 6

    • Luis Garcia Jr. vs Ian Seymour
    • Spencer Jones vs Ian Seymour
    • George Lombard Jr. vs Ian Seymour

    Top 7

    • Jazz Chisholm Jr. vs Ian Seymour
    • Trent Grisham vs Ian Seymour
    • Austin Wells vs Ian Seymour

    Top 8

    • Paul Goldschmidt vs Ian Seymour
    • Ben Rice vs Ian Seymour
    • Cody Bellinger vs Ian Seymour

    Not implied

    • This does not prove pitch-execution failure on the solo home run.
    • This does not establish long-term multi-inning bullpen deployment strategy.

    Limitations

    • Does not evaluate future bullpen role or multi-inning stamina.
    Ian SeymourTampa Bay Rays